Emotional Biosensing: Exploring Critical Alternatives

Emotional biosensing is on the rise in daily life: Technologies use data and algorithms to claim to know how people feel and suggest what they should be doing about it. Prevalent approaches to emotional biosensing are too limited, focusing on the individual, optimization, and normative categorization.

My doctoral research helps explore critical alternatives for emotional biosensing design through design research and conceptual shifts.

In this paper I outline a few conceptual moves and apply them to emotional biosensing: (a) toward materiality, (b) from representation toward performativity, (c) inter-action to intra-action, (d) shifting biopolitics, and (e) shifting affect/desire. This paper contributes (1) synthesizing wide-ranging conceptual lenses, providing analysis connecting them to emotional biosensing design, (2) analyzing selected design exemplars to apply these lenses to design research, and (3) offering my own recommendations for designers and design researchers.

I suggest humility in knowledge claims with emotional biosensing, prioritizing care and affirmation over self-improvement, and exploring alternative desires. I call for critically questioning and generatively re-imagining the role of data in configuring sensing, feeling, 'the good life', and everyday experience.

Noura Howell, John Chuang, Abigail De Kosnik, Greg Niemeyer. 2018. Emotional Biosensing: Exploring Critical Alternatives. Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW'18). pdf

The tiled images are from projects discussed, and credited, in the paper. From top left:

Fox. 2014. Biolesce.

Diagram by me.

Ryokai et al. 2017. Celebrating Laughter.

Gadani. 2010. Porcupine Dress.

Moodmetric.

Howell et al. 2018. Tensions of Data-Driven Reflection.

Microsoft Band.

Howell et al. 2018. Tensions of Data-Driven Reflection.

Feel wristband.

Leaf Urban.

Spire.

Hartman et al. 2015. Monarch.

Devendorf et al. 2016. Dynamic Displays on Clothing.

Spire.

Farahi. 2017. Opale.

2015 - present